Are you ready for the best tasting marshmallow?
You haven't had a Marshmallow until you've had an ARTISAN MARSHMALLOW!
Marshmallows made with passion and pride!
About Us
We are a small company based in Southern New Jersey specializing in handcrafted marshmallows and barrel aged products. Every item we make is made with quality, and local when available, ingredients. Since everything is made by hand, no two are alike! This gives them a wonderful unique quality!
All marshmallows are naturally gluten free, but are not vegan due to the use of gelatin.
All marshmallows are made to order in small batches to ensure quality and freshness, so please allow additional time when placing special orders.
We are always trying new things, and testing the market to see what people like! Keep tabs on us by following along on social media! Don't be afraid to throw out your own ideas! It just might make it on the list!
We know you have many choices of where to spend your money, we greatly appreciate that you chose us!
Locations
We are located on E. Holly Ave right off of Broadway in Historic Pitman. We are right next door to Sherwin Williams Paint Store and Sheryl’s Hair Essentials and across the street from Chloe’s Cream Puffs!
Pitman Location
Flavors and Care
Our Signature Flavors
Signature Vanilla
S'mores
Peanut butter
Caramel
Mint Chocolate Chip
Vermont Maple
Signature Vanilla chocolate chip cookie dough
Cinnamon & sugar
Oreo
Coffee
Toasted Coconut
*We also have multiple other flavors available every week. Check social media for what is available!
**Not all flavors are available every week. Please check social media for up to date offerings. Looking for something special? Place a special order!
Marshmallow care
Marshmallows are the absolute best eaten fresh (in my opinion!). But...some do enjoy letting them sit out so they get a little crust on the outside! My boyfriend's father used to let his peeps sit on top of the fridge for weeks before he enjoyed them! I have even been asked before if I could sell "vintage" marshmallows?!?! I just refer them to the fridge method!
The best way to store your marshmallows is in an airtight container or bag. They will keep well for about 3 weeks. After that, they are still good, just not as fluffy.
For any marshmallows that contain perishable items like fruit, the best way to store those is in the fridge.
It's always great to plan, but most marshmallows don't make it past day 2 in the house!
Pricing
All products are made with quality ingredients like handcrafted peanut butter with local raw honey, handcrafted barrel aged bourbon vanilla, handcrafted caramel, genuine Vermont maple products from Northern Vermont and Ghirardelli chocolate products. We use real (when in season locally) fruit and vegetables in our flavors.
Marshmallow pricing is $30 a pound (with some special orders and flavors being slightly higher).
Pricing for individual boxes can range from $6 to $15 per box. Each box usually weighs between 1/4 lb and 1/2 lb.
Individual favors for showers, party's and events start at $2 per piece up to about $6 per piece with prices ranging due to size and packaging. Platters are also available.
Special orders require a 50% nonrefundable deposit at time of order with balance due at pick up. For your convenience, most forms of payment are accepted.
Please be advised, all special orders need to be in by Sunday night for pick up by Thursday, Friday or Saturday. Some orders will also require additional lead time.
We know each event is special and unique! Are you looking for a specific flavor or have something just right in mind? Let us know! We will do our best to accommodate your request and make your event that much more memorable!
Marshmallow of the Month Club
3 month membership Includes
-(12) gourmet marshmallows delivered every month for 3 consecutive months
-FREE delivery
COST: $85
6 month membership includes
-(12) gourmet marshmallows delivered every month for 6 consecutive months.
-FREE delivery
Cost: $165
12 month membership includes
-(12) gourmet marshmallows delivered every month for 12 consecutive months
-FREE delivery
-FREE BONUS Birthday marshmallows
Cost: $320
current monthly flavors
JANUARY
Assortment
FEBRUARY
Chocolate Chocolate Chip
MARCH
Vermont Maple
APRIL
Lemon
MAY
A Mexican inspired assortment
JUNE
Strawberry
JULY
Blueberry
AUGUST
Peach
SEPTEMBER
Caramel Apple
OCTOBER
Fall inspired assortment
NOVEMBER
Assorted Oreo flavors
DECEMBER
Mint Chocolate Chip
when are they shipped?
Your monthly marshmallow flavors are shipped out approximately the first Wednesday/Thursday every month. In event of a holiday or bad weather, they will ship out the following Wednesday or Thursday. They are shipped priority mail USPS (some may ship UPS on occasion) and should arrive within 3 days from shipment. Tracking information can be provided if needed.
Please note
Flavors and shipment days are subject to change at any time. Feel free to call or email with any questions or concerns. Memberships are nonrefundable.
Refunds will not be given on partially used memberships. No changes or substitutions may be made. All months must be consecutive.
Barrel Aged Items
Barrel aged bourbon based vanilla extract
barrel aged bourbon based extracts - additional flavors
barrel aged bourbon based extracts - additional flavors
Madagascar vanilla beans and Heaven Hill Bourbon are added to an oak barrel to soak for about 8 months. At that time, the now Bourbon Vanilla Extract is ready to bottle in our amber bottles. We have just recently bottled our 3rd edition of our BEST SELLING extract on 10/27/20!
barrel aged bourbon based extracts - additional flavors
barrel aged bourbon based extracts - additional flavors
barrel aged bourbon based extracts - additional flavors
The same process is used for the flavored extracts that is used in making of the vanilla extract. The main difference is the use of a smaller barrel and soak time for some will be a little shorter. We have used coffee, cacao nibs, mint leaves, almonds, maple and Ceylon cinnamon to make a few of our outstanding extracts. While these are excellent for baking, they are also great for coffees, teas and cocktails!
barrel aged Vermont maple syrup
barrel aged bourbon based extracts - additional flavors
barrel aged Vermont maple syrup
In the past, we have used the same barrel that we have aged our Bourbon vanilla extract in to age our Vermont maple syrup. This time, we partnered up with another Jersey business, Jersey Spirits Distilling Co. to use one of their barrels that was just dumped with Patriot's Trail Bourbon, to house or maple syrup from Butternut Mountain Farms in Northern Vermont! We can't wait for this one! It's now ready, and it's amazing!
barrel aged local honey
bourbon vanilla turbinado sugar
barrel aged Vermont maple syrup
After bottling the maple syrup, local honey from Fruitwood Orchards in Monroeville, NJ will go into that same barrel! Since we are waiting for the maple syrup to be finished in order to start this process, it will be a while before this edition of the honey will be ready! Stay tuned!
bourbon vanilla sugar
bourbon vanilla turbinado sugar
bourbon vanilla turbinado sugar
When we are finished using the vanilla beans for making or signature bourbon vanilla extract, we take those beans to make vanilla sugar. The beans are split, scraped and added to a container of organic cane sugar to sit for a few months. During that time, the sugar is mixed and the beans are scraped again. When the time comes, the sugar is jared, beans and all. This makes a great finishing sugar for desserts and craft cocktails.
bourbon vanilla turbinado sugar
bourbon vanilla turbinado sugar
bourbon vanilla turbinado sugar
The same process is used with this sugar as with the cane sugar. We use the Turbinado sugar for this one because the vanilla beans have been soaking in the honey, so you need a more substantial sugar to hold up to the honey. As with the cane sugar, this is also a great finishing sugar for desserts and craft cocktail's! We have recently SOLD OUT of the vanilla sugar, but we do have a CHOCOLATE MINT SUGAR available right now! More vanilla sugar will be available early next year!
Support our Military
Operation Turbo
Donation Marshmallows
Donation Marshmallows
In November of 2010 Operation Turbo’s founder, Dyan Zurick Smith, and her husband went to tour their niece’s ship, the USS STOUT. During the tour their niece Heather mentioned that many of her fellow shipmates never receive mail or packages while away from home. Dyan’s heart sank and she decided that she could change that. Within 48 hours she had reached out to friends, family, neighbors, clients and anyone she knew who was able to help. Through Facebook, Twitter, email, and paper flyers, Dyan and her husband Jeff got the word out. Their mission had begun.
To read more, visit operationturbo.org.
Donation Marshmallows
Donation Marshmallows
Donation Marshmallows
Those of you who know me know I have a special place in my heart for our military. This is why The Artisan Marshmallow Co has teamed up with Operation Turbo to bring to you special edition red, white and blue marshmallows!
🇺🇸 🇺🇸 🇺🇸 🇺🇸 🇺🇸 🇺🇸 🇺🇸
100% of the sale of these marshmallows will go directly to Operation Turbo! If you are not familiar with this wonderful organization, they ship "Boxes of Home" to our deployed service men and women who are selflessly defending our country!
🇺🇸 🇺🇸 🇺🇸 🇺🇸 🇺🇸 🇺🇸 🇺🇸
The style, shape or size of marshmallow might change...but they will always be red, white and blue and our Signature bourbon vanilla!
Available for purchase in our online store or our shop in Pitman!
Want to stay connected?
You definitely do not want to miss out on what’s going on here in The Marshmallow Shop!
Give us your email address so that we can keep you in the loop with all things Marshmallow!